|
Ex- Communists used to ask one another the above question--- so one of them once told me. When did they realise that Communism was not the people’s progressive wave of the future but a murderous dictatorship. Those of us who supported Donald Trump should be asking ourselves the same question. We never believed in a foolish, pseudo-intellectual world-saving doctrine like Communism. But we did believe, often enthusiastically, that we had found a leader who would try to save us from the evil of the Deep State. After all, he knocked off half a dozen empty suit Republican presidential wannabees and spoke freely truths that no Republican leader had sufficient courage and patriotism even to mention. Truths about immigration catastrophe and stupid criminal warmaking. And he stood up to the censorship of the media oligarchy. The simple truth is that we Trump supporters were desperate for any hope of getting a government of the people and this was the best thing we had. But, as Ilana Mercer wisely pointed out in her book The Trump Revolution, it was good that there were new currents flowing in our political system, but we really had no understanding of how it might turn out. We should have looked more carefully at Trump’s character. There have been morally flawed men who were capable Presidents, and society had become more tolerate of indiscretions. But in retrospect Trump has revealed himself to be an immoral bully and braggadocio of the worst New York type - with flaws getting more evident with age. Perhaps guilty of grave misdeeds that the Deep State is using to control his present actions? Still, he was the best item on offer. Perhaps the change in national political deliberation that we thought was due to Trump was actually due to the weakening of the media and spread of internet communication of greatly varied outlets for news and opinion - a happening that a shrewd ambitious salesman took advantage of. I wrote at the time that the choice of Pence as VP was a bad sign - an empty suit Establishment Republican who had no qualities of statesmanship and no real appeal to strengthen the ticket. It was clearly a warning sign that the Establishment still had the power to veto good change and prevent improvement. The same dashing of hope that occurred when Reagan took on Bush in 1980. Trump’s first term achievements were disappointing, but he was still our man. We knew that he had a hard battle to fight. His work on immigration, though insufficient, keeps him a few stars on the board. As Peter Brimelow has written, we had a man good on immigration but now bad on everything else. In 2024 we still hoped and were not prepared for the biggest policy betrayal in U.S. history. It seems to me that the Republican Party is not and never can be the instrument of a populist reform. Its entire history as the party of Big Business makes that impossible. I could say more about the defects and evil history of the Republicans. Instead let a vain old man recommend my book Annals of the Stupid Party.
2 Comments
|
AuthorClyde Wilson is a distinguished Professor Emeritus of History at the University of South Carolina He is the author or editor of over thirty books and published over 600 articles, essays and reviews Archives
November 2026
|