|
The U.S. government’s attack on Iran fails every rule of Christian “just war” theory. It trashes what little is left of the Constitution. And possibly worst of all, it is stupid. Just war principles require action to be taken to protect the innocent or redress grave injury. They require that all peaceful alternatives are exhausted. The war initiated must have a reasonable chance of success. The rule of “proportionality” requires that the costs of action do not outweigh the intended benefit. Churlishly, we attacked while negotiations were under way (like Japs at Pearl Harbor). We murdered the other country’s legitimate leaders, a gangsterism no honest government can justify. Iran offered no grave threat or injury to us. In fact, they sensibly avoided it. True, a half century ago, they violated our embassy in the midst of their revolution to overthrow the absurd “Shah” that we imposed on them. And they have a hostile-talking Islamic government. But they have accepted unjust sanctions and weapons inspections. They know it is not in their interest to provoke the U.S. Incredibly, our Secretary of State said we had to go to war because our little client state was going to war whether we liked it or not. Such was the reason for sacrificing our blood and treasure. Our Founders would have considered this blatant TREASON against the American people. The Israelis have been declaring for over 40 years that Iran will have nuclear weapons with a few weeks or so. This is a lie. The purpose of the lie is to make sure that Israel remains the only nuclear power in the region. President Kennedy was trying to prevent Israel getting nukes when he was killed. Countries want nuclear weapons for defense, as a deterrent. They have not been used since 1945. It might be good if Iran had some, like a number of other countries. It would deter Israeli aggression and dominance. And the U.S. undertook this attempt at regime change, apparently not having noticed that previous such attempts have been catastrophic failures. Our leaders learn nothing and are never held responsible for their mistakes. That is the opposite of government of, by, and for the people. Such leadership is a sign of decadent imperialism. New York thugs like Trump and pretty boys like Rubio cannot make statesmen. The top generals are not soldiers but have risen to the top as a— kissing and backstabbing bureaucrats. Donald Trump promised to avoid such folly. But he has now joined George W. Bush as one of this century’s chief war criminals. How did that happen? We may never know. We were told that once we murdered their leaders, the Iranians would rise up for democracy and peace. The media savants liked this because they see the Iranian dissidents as nice liberals like themselves. To them it seemed OK to bomb useless civilians for a higher good. Are our political and military leaders too ignorant or too deluded by their power to notice facts that don’t fit their shallow view of the world? I doubt if any of our Congresspersons or generals actually know any relevant history. How many of them do you imagine can actually read an Iranian newspaper? Iran is not Iraq. It is a big country of 90 million or so, with highly intelligent scientists, dedicated soldiers, and leaders who actually love and want to serve their people, unlike Western politicians. It is the heir of a once mighty Persian Empire. And, if Islamic extremists are a threat to us, why have our leaders been importing them in hundreds of thousands? For Diversity? By following a sensible and moderate policy, Iran has managed to throw the American “cake walk” into a quagmire. We are apparently expending our high ordinance at a serious rate. It cannot be replaced quickly because our “leaders” have shipped the factories overseas. It is reported that our billion dollar air craft carriers can’t get too close because they can easily be wiped out by enemy missiles. And the U.S.S. Gerald Ford had to be recalled because of sewage problems. Ironically appropriate for a warship named for the shallow man who was never elected and became President only by accident. Sadly, Trump has destroyed all hope for the domestic reform that he promised. The Democrats will regain power and continue us into the Obama-Biden decadence that will finish of the dream of a free and honourable America.
15 Comments
3/30/2026 04:40:11 am
"Trump promised to avoid such folly... How did that happen? We may never know," but "our greatest ally in the Middle East" has been known to offer America "encouragement" to support the Israeli agenda with AIPAC money for bribes, Epstein "honey traps" for blackmail, and Mossad assassinations when all else fails.
Reply
Roberto
3/30/2026 06:08:40 am
The Ford retreated not because of sewage problems. It was struck by a missile fired by the Houthis. The cover story was a fire caused by lint in a dryer. 30 hours to put out a laundry fire? I don't think so.
Reply
Paul Yarbrough
4/1/2026 08:27:55 am
It was India that invented the game of chess, but it was the Persians who refined it and became masters of it.
Reply
Joseph R. Stromberg
4/1/2026 09:06:44 am
Well said, Clyde. At this point, Trump is the leading candidate to be the new Ozymandias. "Nothing beside remains."
Reply
Harry Colin
4/1/2026 06:03:56 pm
So well-stated, Dr. Wilson. The clumsiness and vulgarity of this president and his band of demented sycophants would be hilarious if it were not so deeply destructive. I chuckled at the line about reading an Iranian newspaper; I question this bunch's ability to read one in English. A recent interview of one of the most feverish war cheerleaders, Ted Cruz, proved he is ignorant enough about Iran and the region to have gotten himself tossed out of my 5th grade geography class.
Reply
Aaron
4/4/2026 06:50:33 pm
Dr. Wilson, maybe you see Operation Epic Fury as a mistake but I think it's important not to disregard President Trump's accomplishments. No president is perfect, but Trump is the best one we've had in a long time. Plus, immigration is the most important issue and he's been doing really well in that area. Migration is at a net negative for the first time in many decades. If Kamala were elected instead of Trump, she would allow so much mass migration that our nation would probably be damaged beyond repair. Overall, in my view Trump's 2nd term has been good with some mistakes but we shouldn't forget the successes because of the blunders.
Reply
Clyde N Wilson
4/5/2026 04:49:35 am
Aaron, Given that Trump has done some good, the problem is that the good was limited and he has destroyed any prospect of accomplishing further change. He has almost made sure that the Democrats will get in again and do as you suggest. And it is unforgivable that he has turned on some of best friends.
Reply
Aaron
4/5/2026 05:57:05 pm
First, I just want to say that I deeply respect you and your viewpoint on the Trump admin in its current hour. I am but a high schooler who doesn’t have close to the knowledge you have on history and politics. There’s been significant mistakes besides the recent intervention in Iran. The situation with the Epstein Files was poorly handled. Though there’s no evidence that Trump abused minors, and he actually called the cops on Epstein, the cover-up of the files by other people in his admin has made him seem incredibly suspicious. As a younger guy, I have noticed the decreasing “hype” behind the president among the people I know and on social media. Only a year and a half ago, the most common position, even with many liberals, was to support Trump. Now, most, like you, dislike him and view him as a power-hungry, corrupt man. Conservatives have not been divided like now at any point during the MAGA era. The assassination of Charlie Kirk by an insane leftist contributed to this mess, as he acted as a “gatekeeper” to keep nut jobs like “Hitler’s New Fans”, whom you have written about, out of the conservative movement. Now, these folks are dominating social media and encouraging young people to sit out elections and blame Jewish people for all the problems in this country. Regardless of how you feel about Kirk, he was open to many of your ideas unlike the average Fox News talking head. He was strongly against mass migration, both legal and illegal, and spoke against the Civil Rights Act of 1964. Mr. Kirk was also deeply committed to his Christian faith and, though he was a Zionist for most of his political career, towards the end of his life he spoke against the Israel Lobby's influence in American politics. Despite all the negatives I just presented, the solution to our current situation is not to accept defeat. Quite the opposite. We should be encouraging young conservative men to join ICE, the State Department, GOP circles, and the government in general. I should note that the State Department is currently hiring people to be in charge of accepting/rejecting VISAs. It would be great to have young patriots in this position. Lindsey Graham and other bad news neocons got the power they have by shaking hands and working their way up the ladder for many years. It’s boring and unglamorous, but I see it as necessary for people like us to do the same if we want to take over the GOP. Secession, national divorce, and building a new right-wing party aren’t realistic at this time. From my perspective, the best chance at reshaping our country back into a government by and for the people is for genuine patriots to infiltrate the Republican Party from the bottom up and get into positions of power. Refusing to vote in elections and posting conspiracy theories about the moon landing on the internet gets us nowhere (not saying that you are doing that. I am just pointing out that many "conservative" figures are). The recent election for governor of Virginia has showed us this. Though the GOP candidate was terrible, she would not have softened punishment for felonies, reinstated DEI, and ended the state's cooperation with ICE like the current Dem governor has. I know that you will probably disagree with me, but I hope you can at least see the merit in what I am saying. Have a great Easter, Dr. Wilson.
Reply
Clyde N Wilson
4/6/2026 05:55:31 am
Dear Aaron. Your comments and thoughts are certainly outstanding for a high-schooler. I encourage you to continue reading and thinking. Thank you for reading and commenting here. You are on the true path. Intelligent independent thinking is a rare thing in American society.
Reply
Aaron
4/6/2026 07:15:49 pm
If you don't mind me asking, who exactly were the young people entering government service in the 1960s and which agencies did they join? What were their goals? I would like to research this.
Reply
Clyde N Wilson
4/7/2026 08:19:16 am
Aaron, I seem to have accidentally posted my comments before they were finished. The Republican party is not and never has been a conservative party, except for conserving corporate profits and the comfortable position of the leaders. Since the New Deal, the Republicans in Congress have never put up any real opposition to any leftist movement. In cases such as the Civil Right Acts and giving citizenship to illegal immigrants, the Republicans have abetted revolution.
Clyde N Wilson
4/7/2026 07:58:34 am
Aaron. It is a pleasure to see you thinking so seriously about our sad condition. I agree with you that immigration is the most important issue. Trump's appointees seem to have been working well to close the border and to remove criminal aliens. A lot more need to be removed, not just the criminals. Now that Trump has discredited himself, I fear that immigration enforcement has slowed down and will be reversed when the Demos gain power. And Trump seems to have approved Indian ID workers, the worst offense of all. He joins all the other capitalists in this preference.
Reply
Anthony Powell
4/13/2026 06:33:06 pm
Has anyone here read Dr Pezeshkian’s letter to the American people. Contrast the eloquence of this man to the boorish, vulgar, inarticulate Trump. The difference between their intellects is astonishing.
Reply
Aaron
4/14/2026 05:41:25 pm
Mr. Powell, perhaps Dr. Pezeshkian's letter was eloquently written. I have not read it. However, I find his mastery of writing to be an unimportant detail considering that Iran has been a thorn in our country's side for many years. Perhaps you disagree with much of our foreign intervention, as do I, but it is inexcusable that Iran held about 60 American civilians and diplomats hostage for over a year. Though this was almost 50 years ago, the same Ayatollah regime that Dr. Pezeshkian currently supports was responsible for the Iran Hostage Crisis. It is not advantageous for us to go to war with this nation, but this does not make them our friend. I want to also note that Iran acts as a bully to its neighbors in the Middle East by bombing them and funding radical terrorist groups which cause chaos throughout the region. It was not just Israel but many of the gulf states which begged Trump to initiate this conflict with Iran. These other nations are just less loud about forwarding their interests, which is why most of the attention is on Israel. None of this especially concerns American interests, I just wanted to put this man Dr. Pezeshkian and the Iranian government as a whole in context. Fortunately, the skirmish with Iran seems to be winding down. There is currently a ceasefire in effect and a compromise is being worked out. Let's hope that this comes to an end as soon as possible so attention can be drawn back to more important matters, like mass deportations. Maybe you totally disagree with my perspective, but I hope you can see where I’m coming from. If you would like to discuss more about why I strongly support President Trump, I would be glad to continue chatting.
Aaron
4/14/2026 06:20:39 pm
I forgot to mention that the Iranian regime is frequently cited as one of the most persecuting countries towards Christians. House churches are regularly raided and converting to Christianity from Islam (“apostasy”) is considered a serious crime with extreme consequences. Those churches which are allowed under their laws are almost exclusively Armenian and Assyrian, and they are barred from doing service in Persian (the main language in Iran). These Christians also don’t enjoy many of the legal rights that Muslim Iranians enjoy. Basically, they are an oppressed minority forced to keep their faith to themselves. Leave a Reply. |
AuthorClyde Wilson is a distinguished Professor Emeritus of History at the University of South Carolina He is the author or editor of over thirty books and published over 600 articles, essays and reviews Archives
April 2026
|