|
Over the summer, moviegoers enjoyed Christopher Nolan’s reimagining of “The Odyssey,” which included the iconic story of the Trojan Horse. A parting gift to the Trojans by the Greeks, who had apparently given up their 10-year siege and gone home, the great horse secretly housed an elite band of Greek warriors under the command of Odysseus, who once inside the impregnable walls opened the gates for their comrades lying in wait and conquered the city. This fall, Floridians are facing a referendum that is another Trojan Horse, a gift on the outside concealing a danger within. There are three amendments on the ballot, two that are relatively mundane, increasing the percentage of funds that the state government may save in the event of an unexpected shortfall,[1] a personal-property tax exemption for agricultural and agritourist properties,[2] and “Amendment 3.” The root word for economics, oikos, Greek for “home,” originally referred to the management of the household, and as with any household the government saving money is prudent. Few wish to object to tax relief for farmers, but this amendment fails to distinguish between the image evoked by the word “farmer,” those for whom it is a vocation and a tradition, such as the late Wendell Berry, and the gargantuan agribusinesses that are more industrial than agrarian and who are, in fact, one of the causes of the plight of authentic farmers. Yet it is Amendment 3 that ought to be of gravest concern. Befitting a Trojan Horse, there are two parts to this amendment, one that is innocuous, another that is insidious. The first part raises the non-school homestead tax exemption from $25,000 to $150,000 in 2027, then to $250,000 in 2028. Contrary to some demagoguery from those in favor of higher taxes, this is the “non-school” property tax, meaning that the property taxes collected by school districts will not be affected. Obviously, property taxes are potentially regressive, as a property owner may not necessarily have the liquidity to pay annual taxes on his property, hence the limits on “millage,” the limits on the annual increase in assessed value, and the homestead exemption. Yet the current homestead exemption, a fractional amount of the assessed value of even low-value homes, is too low to serve its intended purpose. Amidst swelling inflation, which is eating into real incomes and tightening budgets, the need for this overdue reform is all the more urgent. Short of declaring independence in order to reclaim the powers which by right belong to free and independent states, Florida cannot do anything directly about the monetary policy that fundamentally propels inflation, nor the slipshod tariffs that the president haphazardly imposes on foreign countries out of pique and spite, nor the global energy crisis caused by the president’s rogue war on Iran, nor inefficient and inequitable healthcare system beyond treating its progressively worsening symptoms. There is the Jeffersonian and Madisonian recourse of “nullification,” whereby a state declares an act of the federal government unconstitutional, the states convene to adjudicate the matter, and the Constitution is amended accordingly.[3] Alas, whatever party controls the federal government tends to disparage any exercise of states’ rights as “neo-Confederate,” no matter how removed in time and place from slavery, whereas whatever party does not control the federal government opportunistically invokes states’ rights until it returns to power, whereupon it opportunistically disavows them yet again. Contrast the respective reactions of the Red Party to Red-State Texas’ resistance to the Feds in 2024 (when the Blues were the Feds) and Blue-State Minnesota’s resistance to the Feds in 2025 (when the Reds were the Feds). This uninspiring cycle of unprincipled partisanship, endemic to democracy, has left the limitations of power in our Constitution dead on the page—what the “Father of the Constitution” James Madison dismissed as “parchment barriers”—hence the president can usurp both the power of the purse and the sword with impunity, something not even the mad king against whom we revolted would have dared! What the state government can do, then, and moreover, what it has the will to do, is update its homestead exemption so that it provides substantial as opposed to marginal tax relief. In this respect, then, Amendment 3 ought to be un-controversial and non-partisan, although in my opinion it ought to be legislation rather than a constitutional amendment. The second part of Amendment 3, however, is not just controversial and partisan, but outrightly un-democratic. The second part controls what local governments can spend, limiting it to “public safety, education and schools, infrastructure, natural resources, bond debt service, retirement benefits for employees, and operations and administration.” How dare the state government presume to control how local governments spend their own tax revenue? If there is any authentic American idea, it is self-government, and the more decentralized and localized self-government is, the more authentic it is. Amendment 3 would turn the Aristotelian, Aquinian, and Althusian principle of subsidiarity, the established solution to the political problem of size and scale, upside-down.[4] For example, Thomas Jefferson, who has gone down in history as “the Father of Democracy” and “the Father of State Rights,”[5] went beyond federalism, envisioning within an “empire of liberty”—a continent of multiple American confederacies along the Atlantic, Mississippi, and Pacific—an even more decentralized America of “ward republics.”[6] Modeled after New England’s townships, such as Salem,[7] with political identities that predated their state and the United States, this radical democratic localism was “the wisest invention ever devised by the wit of man for the perfect exercise of self-government and for its preservation.” These small, human-scaled governments would be responsible “for all those concerns which, being under their eye, they would better manage than the larger republics of the county or State,” such as “the care of their poor, their roads, police, elections, the nomination of jurors, administration of justice in small cases, elementary exercises of militia,” and especially education. In his memoirs, Jefferson expounded upon the logic of government from the bottom-up as opposed to from the top-down, once more referring to his ward-republic utopia:
“There are two subjects indeed, which I shall claim a right to further as long as I breathe: The public education and the subdivision of counties into wards,” he declared to Joseph C. Cabell, a future co-founder of the University of Virginia. “I consider the continuance of republican government as absolutely hanging on these two hooks.” Needless to say, this is not the Jefferson of the “PragerU” videos foisted upon Floridian schoolchildren. Would a government comprised of the people of a city not be more representative of the people of that city than a government comprised of people from other cities? Would a city government not be more responsible to the people of their own city than a government comprised of those responsible to the people of other cities? Would a city government not be better stewards of the revenue which it has raised from its own people than a government spending other people’s money? There is a surfeit of sermonizing about “protecting our democracy” nowadays, primarily focused on the preserving mere forms of democracy, but by sundering the connection between the taxing and the spending power, this undermines the very foundations of democracy. How ironic for the Red Party, after all its trumpeting about the “Free State of Florida,” stumbling—on America’s 250th birthday, no less—into a new form of “taxation without representation”! By combining a popular measure (updating an outdated homestead exemption amidst a homeownership and affordability crisis) with a measure that would be otherwise extremely unpopular (overruling home rule), the Red Party which voted this amendment through the legislature are scheming to consolidate their party’s power in the state capital and defund Blue local governments, not to mention insulting the intelligence and integrity of the electorate. There is plenty that Blue local governments have done that I oppose—despise even—but preserving the principle of democracy must remain paramount. Popular amongst the Blues at every level of government and in every section of the United States for the past ten years has been the destruction of historic monuments and memorials in the name of righting the wrong of slavery. Driven by some combination of guilt (that worketh death), pride (that goeth before the fall), and vengeance (that belongeth to the Lord), this witch hunt has been terribly unhealthy for anything like civility and unity, in effect normalizing political violence by proxy. For me personally, the knowledge that knee-jerk reactions by know-nothings are inflicting permanent damage on our heritage, at turns saddens and enrages me. Between this iconoclasm, the leveling and paving over of everything green for “development,” the normalization of facemasks and other Covid-era dystopianism, and now the ubiquity of soulless AI “art,” the utter ugliness of the world, as well as its capacity to plumb new depths of ugliness hitherto unfathomable, is simply staggering. Although the state government bungled legislation in 2024 that would have protected monuments and memorials, under this amendment they could receive ironclad protection. Where does tearing down a century-old statue fit under “public safety, education and schools, infrastructure, natural resources, bond debt service, retirement benefits for employees, and operations and administration”? Yet to do so would be out of the question, for it would consummate the destruction of those symbols by destroying what they symbolize: Self-government, the proposition to which America is truly dedicated. As David Levy Yulee, the “father of Florida’s statehood” and America’s first Jewish Senator, foretold as he bade farewell to the U.S. Senate after Florida seceded from the Union, “She sees fast rising above all others the great issue of the right of the people of the States to sovereignty and self-government within their respective territorial boundaries.” Against “a general tendency in the public mind to a theory of the Constitution, and to principles of construction, which must convert this Government into an unlimited despotism,” Yulee pledged that Florida was “prepared to devote the lives and fortunes of all her people.” Yulee’s colleague, Stephen Mallory, also bidding adieu to the Senate, admitted that forming a republican government was a challenge under any conditions, let alone under the storm clouds of civil war, but confidently concluded that “so well are human rights and national liberty understood by our people; so deeply are they imbued with the spirit of freedom and knowledge of government, that were this Republic utterly broken and destroyed, like the shattered vase of the poet, to whose very fragments the scent of the roses still clung, its very ruins breathing the true spirit of civil and religious liberty, would plead for and demand a wise and noble reconstruction.” Just as I would not dare tear down a statue, even of my enemy,[8] so too I would not dare take away a local government’s ability to spend its own taxes—to govern itself—even if that means my enemy tearing down a statue of my hero. To leave these statues standing while toppling what they stood for would be a travesty, and unlike those who, for example, tilt at a statue of a man sitting harmlessly on a park bench by the eastern terminus of the railroad he founded,[9] I still have a sense of shame. Do those succumbing to this disturbing un-democratic impulse not understand that they are setting a precedent which can, as the political wheel turns, be used against them? Or are they not so callow after all, and rather are unprincipledly assuming that they will always be in the statewide majority, the ones overruling how local majorities spend their money, not the ones in the local minority being overruled? Perhaps they will, but while Florida’s Reds outnumber Florida’s Blues for the time being (41% to 30%), independents and third parties still hold the balance of power between them (28%), and they tend not to favor corrupt partisanship and ideological extremism.[10] Yet under the expansive language of this amendment, a local government could justify any conceivable expenditure under one of the authorized categories. What does “public safety, education and schools, infrastructure, natural resources, bond debt service, retirement benefits for employees, and operations and administration” not arguably encompass? Creating further confusion, the amendment also states, “Other expenditures may be approved by county officers or county or municipal governing bodies unless prohibited by general law, notwithstanding Article VII, Section 9(a) of the Florida Constitution, which allows counties and municipalities to levy property taxes for their respective purposes.” So, to public safety, education and schools, infrastructure, natural resources, bond debt service, retirement benefits for employees, and operations and administration, add “other.” Helluva job, fellas! How will this amendment therefore be enforced? With litigation, making the business of government even more expensive and inefficient than it is at present. Budgets will be set not by elected officials, but in court, through exhausting legalistic arguments over whether this road repair qualifies as “infrastructure,” whether that school program qualifies as “education,” and so and so forth, to say nothing about the category of “other.” In effect, this amendment spells more rule by judges, the least democratic branch of the American systems of government. The Red Party has bafflingly blundered with this amendment, and in so doing has betrayed its undemocratic designs on Florida. What ought to have been an un-controversial and non-partisan vote has instead become unnecessarily divisive, alienating even stalwart Red bastions, such as the Florida Sheriffs Association.[11] As opposed to shrewdly baiting some of the more tactless Blues into opposing what is, in effect, a common-sense and long-overdue update to the homestead exemption, in turn tainting their party at large, the Reds are the ones who have politicized this vote and afforded the Blues the winning rhetoric for the stump: “Protect [insert your local government program of choice here] from top-down micro-management in the state capital!” Emblematic of the Red Party’s internal dysfunction, the initial draft of the amendment that the Red-Party legislature submitted to the public included language so impolitic and partisan that it was ordered to be rewritten so as to comply with the state constitution.[12] Because the Reds were unable to conduct themselves with dignity and treated a constitutional amendment as if it were a party press release, they unnecessarily incurred bad press for their own agenda. The corruption of Florida’s Red Party illustrates the dangers of any state government becoming the monopoly of a party, whether “Red” or “Blue.” The American systems of government, at every level, are founded on “checks and balances,” and that applies no less to the extra-constitutional party system. Without a minority party effectively checking and balancing its power, forcing the majority to stay competitive and make compromises, the latter becomes insular, complacent, and dysfunctional, and is in danger of political implosion. How better to explain the elevation of someone like “Byron Donalds,” an affirmative-actioned Trump kiss-ass and data-center shill? Only a party so inward-facing that it has become politically inbred would nominate such a clown as its candidate for the highest office in the state. John Wallace, Black Republican legislator in Florida during Reconstruction, this guy ain’t![13] “Power corrupts,” true, but “powerlessness corrupts,” too. Have Florida’s Blues, which since 2018 have suffered so many losses that this onetime battleground state has been declared a “Red State,” moderated in order to stop alienating the public, or have they become even more extreme? On the one hand, they just nominated Angie Nixon, a “democratic socialist,” for Senate, though to be fair her opponent, Alex Vindman, a Ukraine-firster carpet-bagging for office in Florida, was no better.[14] On the other hand, they nominated David Jolly for Governor, a former member of the Red Party stumping on all the standard issues and spouting traditional Blue rhetoric as opposed to, say, hyper-personalized and hyper-polarized peak-2020 woke politics.[15] It remains to be seen whether the Blues can overcome ressentiment and return to being a competitive, constructive force in Florida politics. I oppose Amendment 3, albeit with sincere regrets and severe resentment towards its authors. The Red state government which submitted this amendment to the public compromised an increase to the homestead exemption, which we desperately need, with an insidious assault on home rule. May this act of hubris go down to a deserved defeat! In the Aeneid, the Roman epic which continues the story of the Iliad and the Odyssey from a Trojan perspective, a Trojan priest named Laocoön remonstrates with his compatriots not to bring the Trojan Horse into the city. “Beware of Greeks bearing gifts,” he warns in vain. Likewise, Floridian voters this fall would be well-advised to beware of amendments bearing tax cuts. This essay, of matters respecting human beings, by a human being, and for other human beings, was written without any use of artificial intelligence. NOTES
[1] “Florida Changes to Budget Stabilization Fund Amendment.” Ballotpedia. https://tinyurl.com/2kyk7e9c [2] “Florida Exempt Tangible Personal Property Used for Agriculture or Agritourism from Property Taxes Amendment.” Ballotpedia. https://tinyurl.com/bdh676uj [3] Woods, Tom. Nullification: How to Resist Federal Tyranny in the 21st Century. Washington D.C.: Regnery, 2010. [4] Livingston, Donald. “American Republicanism and the Forgotten Question of Size,” in Rethinking the American Union for the Twenty-First Century, edited by Donald Livingston. Gretna: Pelican Publishing Company, 2012. [5] Peterson, Merrill D. The Jefferson Image in the American Mind. Charlottesville: Thomas Jefferson Memorial Foundation, 1998. [6] Thomas Jefferson, who came to view New England, with its High Federalist “Tories” and “psalm-singing” Puritans, as a nemesis to republicanism, nonetheless credited its wards with “the vigour given to our revolution in its commencement,” and confessed that he felt his presidency “tremble under the remonstrances” of the wards, which with an audacity he could not help but admire, nullified the embargo acts on Great Britain and threatened seceding from the Union over the Louisiana Purchase. [7] “Amy Kittredge is my name. “Salem is my dwelling place. “New England is my nation. “And Christ is my salvation.” —quoted from Albion’s Seed: Four British Folkways in America, by David Hackett Fischer (Oxford University Press, 1991) [8] The chapter “A Statue of My Enemy” in Wendell Berry’s latest book, The Need To Be Whole, is a revelation in its exhibition of magnanimity and grace, and a rebuke to those petty, nasty ideologues and iconoclasts who roam history in search of enemies, then roam the land search of their statues to destroy. [9] Lednovich, Mike. “America at 250: It’s time to put the David Yulee statue in its proper place.” Fernandina Observer. June 29, 2026. https://tinyurl.com/zdt89vpy [10] “Voter Registration by Party Affiliation.” dos.fl.gov. Florida Division of Elections. https://tinyurl.com/ce3j8yxw [11] Polk Sheriff. “Sheriff Grady Judd’s Comments on Amendment 3.” August 4, 2026. https://tinyurl.com/mpwkrvem [12] Sexton, Christine. “Amendment 3 ballot title, summary language, don’t pass muster, judge rules.” Florida Phoenix. August 4, 2026. https://tinyurl.com/bdhwm97k [13] Wallace, John. Carpet-Bag Rule in Florida. University of Florida Press, 1888. [14] Mahoney, Emily L. “Nixon pulls off upset win in Florida’s Democratic U.S. Senate primary.” Tampa Bay Times. August 18, 2026. https://tinyurl.com/yh8rdadh [15] Sickler, Michael Van. “Byron Donalds, David Jolly win, setting up historic Florida governor race.” ibid. https://tinyurl.com/4c5vftcx
7 Comments
|
AuthorJames Rutledge Roesch is a businessman and an amateur writer. He lives in Florida with his wife, daughter, and dog Archives
October 2026
|
Proudly powered by Weebly