 The Prussians (a German people) were a people that are by and large no more because once uprooted from your ancestral homeland you cease to be that people. Just like the British that settled the American South became Southerners (or today just plain Americans) and ceased to be English or Scottish or Scotch-Irish. And peoples are similar to individuals because they are by nature composed of individuals, individuals that collectively are a people because they share space through time that has produced commonalities, or a unique culture. Peoples, like individuals, have their own personality that is easily observed by other peoples. Southerners are, or Southern culture is, no exception. The poor Prussians! The long march of history would make of the Prussians a warlike, relentless, and efficient people that would bring them to the greatest catastrophe and triumph of modern German history, namely the crushing Prussian (slash-German) victory over the French in the Franco-Prussian war of 1870-71. ‘But Mark, fool. How could their victory be a catastrophe?’ Because victory can be transformative, confirming, and addictive. Ask any failed gambler. Their victory over the hapless French (who honestly earned that ass-whipping) confirmed the military temperament and culture of the Prussians and addicted the German people generally to marshal glory and gave them an inflated idea of themselves, which would encourage them to go all-in in 1914 and then again in 1939, chasing that winning hand and victor’s high. The rest is history. What is not well known is that after 1945 the Prussians, along with their border, were relocated en masse westward and Prussia for all practical purposes ceased to exist. The classic example of living and dying by the sword. Southerners are not Prussians but we are the warrior people of America and America has never fought a war that we did not approve. But we need to temper our war-like temperament. If Uncle Sam says ‘Boys, lock and load!’ we must insist that he tell us why, and not speak to us as though we are a high school football team about to take the field, but rather as adults who can understand geo-politics, and the need to make collective sacrifices from time to time. This piece was published at Look Away on July 18, 2023.
5 Comments
WES
7/28/2023 06:52:57 am
I stand pretty much with Murray Rothbart when he contended that there were only two wars fought by Americans that were just and noble due to the fact that those Americans who fought in those wars were either occupied and/or invaded: such wars were the American War for Independence (1775-1783) and the Southern War for Independence (1861-65). The rest of the bloody wars we fought were, for the most part, unjust or ignoble driven by a lust for conquest, empire or twisted ideology.
WES
7/28/2023 03:09:09 pm
...Murray ROTHBARD... 7/29/2023 07:49:59 am
It isn’t that our (Dutch) Uncle Sam doesn’t tell us “why”. It is that he so often lies. The list of war-lies is long and long and longer. The manifold collection of government lies that he has created is as voluminous as the stars. 7/29/2023 04:50:43 pm
You sound just like me. I have often said if the govt. told me the sun would rise in the East then I'd check the sky in the West.
William Smith
7/30/2023 06:24:30 am
I stand at my Confederate ancestors' graves, having placed a 3rd National Confederate flag on or about June 3rd each year (Confederate Memorial Day here in TN, along with President Davis's birthday, as you all know), and I utter a quiet "Thank you for your service!" each time. Leave a Reply. |
